Automated Essay Scoring feedback for second language writers: How exactly does it compare to instructor feedback?

Automated Essay Scoring feedback for second language writers: How exactly does it compare to instructor feedback?


We compared Automated Essay instructor and scoring feedback in a ESL class.

Feedback on grammar, usage, and mechanics had been analyzed and pupils had been surveyed.

Perceived quality of feedback has also been examined by an additional ESL teacher.

Outcomes revealed the instructor supplied more quality feedback compared to the AES system.

Most pupils trusted AES feedback, yet rated teacher feedback much more valuable.


Writing 123helpme is a component that is essential of’ educational English development, yet it entails a quite a bit of effort and time regarding the element of both students and instructors. In order to reduce their workload, many trainers are searching in to the use of Automated Essay Scoring (AES) systems to check more conventional means of supplying feedback. This paper investigates the usage an AES system in a college ESL classroom that is writing. Participants included 14 higher level pupils from various linguistic backgrounds who penned on three prompts and received feedback through the trainer and also the AES system (Criterion). Instructor feedback regarding the drafts (n = 37) ended up being when compared with AES feedback and analyzed both quantitatively and qualitatively over the feedback kinds of sentence structure ( e.g., subject-verb contract, ill-formed verbs), usage ( e.g., wrong articles, prepositions), mechanics ( e.g., spelling, capitalization), and recognized quality by one more ESL trainer. Information had been triangulated with viewpoint studies student that is regarding associated with the feedback received. The outcomes reveal large discrepancies between your two feedback kinds (the trainer supplied many better quality feedback) and suggest essential pedagogical implications by providing writing that is ESL with insights concerning the utilization of AES systems inside their classrooms.

Previous article in problem Next article in problem


Semire Dikli received her Ph.D. in Multilingual-Multicultural Education at Florida State University. She’s got taught English for Academic needs (EAP) along with other English being a language that is second/foreignESL/EFL) associated courses in both the U.S. as well as in Turkey. Her research passions consist of composing technology and assessment.

Susan Bleyle is an assistant teacher of English for Academic Purposes at Georgia Gwinnett university and a student that is doctoral Language and Literacy Education in the University of Georgia. Her research passions consist of third language acquisition, the training of developmental immigrant students, and 2nd language writing.

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse de messagerie ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *